Exceptional Hardship

What is Exceptional Hardship

There is no strict definition of the term “Exceptional Hardship” and each case will depend on its own merits and circumstances.  As a general observation, it is important to note that the hardship suffered must be “exceptional”.  It should, therefore, go beyond what would normally be suffered by someone who loses their licence.  As such, loss of employment in itself is unlikely to satisfy the Exceptional Hardship test.  However, if it can also be established that the loss of employment will have a knock on effect and so cause hardship to other persons then this might amount to Exceptional Hardship.

Examples of Exceptional Hardship

There are no hard and fast rules as to what circumstances might amount to Exceptional Hardship and often a combination of circumstances may provide the best prospect for success.  These include:

• Loss of employment
• Loss of business
• Ill health or disability
• Loss of home
• Hardship to employer
• Hardship to employees
• Inability to pay loans
• Hardship to family members

In all cases the driver facing disqualification will have to show that he has taken steps to minimise the impact that losing his licence will have, such as looking for alternative employment.  In these circumstances, the court should consider the current economic climate and the availability of alternative jobs.  If a driver is unlikely to find alternative employment because of his age or lack of skills then these are factors that should also be considered by the court.

Procedure for Exceptional Hardship

An application for Exceptional Hardship must be raised by the driver at the time of sentence.  This happens at the point at which a driver is convicted or where he accepts he committed the offence and pleads guilty.  In the normal course of events, once an application for Exceptional Hardship has been made the court will fix a date for a hearing which is called an Exceptional Hardship Proof.  Strictly speaking the court should firstly decide on the number of penalty points that should be endorsed on the licence and then consider the question of Exceptional Hardship.  However, it is also common for courts to consider the question of Exceptional Hardship first and then decide on the number of points.  Regardless of the procedure that is adopted, penalty points must be imposed.

The onus or responsibility is on the driver to prove that Exceptional Hardship is likely to result from the loss of his licence and that that would justify the court in making a finding of Exceptional Hardship.  In practice the driver will require to give evidence and lead other evidence to support his application for Exceptional Hardship.  If this evidence is not accepted by the prosecutor the driver can be cross-examined and the evidence challenged.  Conversely, the prosecutor may accept what is said by the driver.  In this situation, the court can simply hear submissions in the absence of evidence.

The Court’s Decision

At the conclusion of the hearing the court will decide whether or not Exceptional Hardship has been established. If the Exceptional Hardship argument is successful, the court will impose penalty points and then order that no disqualification is made or reduce the period of disqualification.  This decision is recorded on the driving licence and it is important to note that a driver cannot rely on the same grounds to support another application for Exceptional Hardship within a three year period.

If the argument for Exceptional Hardship is unsuccessful the court will impose the appropriate number of points and disqualify the driver for a minimum period of 6 months.  The period of disqualification increases to 12 months if the driver has been previously disqualified.

On a positive note, disqualification under totting-up has the effect of “wiping the slate clean” so that all the points that resulted in the ban will be removed from the licence.